Drakes Bay Oyster Company in west Marin County does not survive. Sharp Park Golf Course in Pacifica does survive.
Pacifica Tribune/John Blanchard, Columnist, 1/1/12. "A left coast view."
 |
| Drakes Bay Oyster Company (DBOC) lease terminated * |
"For
this view from the Left Coast we begin with a meander through the
bucolic, pastoral green hills of West Marin out to Drakes Estero, a
four-fingered inlet of Drakes Bay just north of San Francisco. Passing
grazing livestock and waterfowl through the rolling farmland a left
turn takes us on a bumpy, gravel road leading down to the tidal flats of
Drakes Estero and the
Drakes Bay Oyster Company. Oyster farming has
existed in Drakes Estero for about a hundred years. The Johnson Oyster
Company developed and utilized sustainable farming techniques to grow
their oysters for 60 years. In 2004 the Lunny family, who had been
farming in those hills for four generations and known for their
certified organic, grass fed beef cattle, purchased the oyster company
to continue the tradition.
In 1976 Congress established the Point
Reyes National Seashore that encompasses this area. Several local farms
were designated 'historic' and, along with the oyster operation, were
allowed to stay. West Marin has been at the forefront of sustainable
farming methods for decades and continues this nature friendly industry
today. As stated, DBOC is also an adherent to environmentally sensitive
farming methods. However,
an overzealous group of environmentalists have
used misleading and misrepresented scientific studies to convince the
National Park Service to terminate DBOC's lease this past November. This
is not only a shame, as a traditional family business with about 30
workers will be shut
down, but an environmental faux pas as well. DBOC is the only California
oyster farm and produces almost half of what the state consumes. The
demand is not going to go away. The replacement proteins will now be
shipped in from Asia or the east coast. What kinds of carbon footprint
conditions were considered in this move?
 |
| Sharp Park Golf Course survives thanks to golfer/legal/city effort |
The irony of this
truly non-progressive mixed bag of environmental policies we have is in
force just a short way down the road from here. As the migrating
waterfowl that are attracted to the Estero fly just over the hill to
Tomales Bay State Preserve a mile or two to the east they are picked off
one by one by hunters hiding in the marsh as this parcel is managed by
the California State Department of Fish and Game. This far thinking
organization, which we pay for, preserves the natural world so that it
may be hunted and fished for sport. Recall the (knuckle)-Head of this
Department smiling broadly to the camera as he hoisted the carcass of a
wild cougar that his dogs chased up a tree in Idaho and he shot in cold
blood. In Idaho, by the way, because California, at least, bans killing
mountain lions for sport.
Many State and Federal agencies and
nonprofit groups have been established with the well-intended aspiration
of conserving and protecting our natural environment. Emotionally it
feeds our soul. Intelligently we have amassed quite a bit of information
that teaches us that our wellbeing and, in fact, our continued
existence is dependent upon living with our environment rather than in
spite of it. But individually, it seems, our views are all over the
place as to why and how we do this.
Bringing it back home,
Pacifica has recently escaped the foolery of this jumbled understanding
of environmentalism. The Endangered Species Act is an important
legislation passed by the U.S. Congress in 1973. The ESA has its basis
in Ecology which is the study of the relationships between living
organisms and their natural environment. Our Biosphere is made up of
numerous ecosystems that are all interrelated to each other. An effect
on one organism can disrupt the entire ecosystem.
This is why six
environmental groups sued to have the Sharp Park Golf Course shut down
to preserve these listed species. But finally common sense won out. Last
October a biological opinion by the U.S. Department of Fish and
Wildlife considered that the facility could be managed in such a way
that would not further endanger the garter snake and the red legged frog
and could continue its operation. The opinion also provided a list of
terms and conditions that must be incorporated into the maintenance of
the course.
Why couldn't that farming family in West Marin be given a
similar list of conditions?
Sharp Park is a beautiful and historic
course. It does not generate an enormous amount of traffic but it is
used and, like DBOC, should be able to exist and be used naturally into
perpetuity. Luckily for us it looks like, at least, SPGC will.
"
Related article - San Francisco Chronicle/Peter Fimrite and Justin Berton, 11/29/12. "US evicting Point Reyes oyster farmer", article includes 30 photographs. " U.S. Interior Secretary Ken Salazar
told a popular oyster farm at Drakes Bay on Thursday to pack up and
leave, effectively ending more than a century of shellfish harvesting on
the picturesque inlet where Europeans first set foot in California. Salazar's decision ends a long-running dispute between the
Drakes Bay Oyster Co. and the National Park Service
over the estuary at Point Reyes National Seashore where Sir Francis Drake landed more than 400 years ago.
"
* Note: photograph by Chris Steward, #29 from the article.
Drakes Bay Oyster Company was formerly Johnson Oyster Company (2005).
Reference - Drakes Bay Oyster Company website.
Posted by Kathy Meeh